Hacker News Reader

Comment by ehsanu1 | Hacker News Reader

What dependencies are required? I would have thought that for basic, no-frills use, you could just load react.js and use it with no other dependencies. Are you referring to the tooling setup required for JSX? I've never used react, just curious.

View on HN

    react_demo$ du -sh node_modules/
    25M     node_modules/
    react_demo$ ls node_modules/|wc -l
    79
    react_demo$ cat $(find node_modules/ -type f ) | wc -l
    287767

I think I installed react, react-dom, browserify (globally), babel. The exact details are not really important, being inexperienced with react I probably installed stuff that is not strictly necessary. However, the ease of pulling in a huge amount of dependent code makes me concerned. For a long lived stable application you will have to maintain those dependencies (at a minimum, have 3rd party maintainers who you can trust to maintain it, not break your app, not inject security issues into your app, etc).

Have had the same experience tonight - browserify etc 12 modules, 75MB, circa 12,000 files. I guess it's just the npm way but it's definitely a bit shocking for those of us who are unfamiliar with it.

That's amazing. I had no idea things were so bad.

But are those strictly react dependencies? Seems more like a demo that was doing a lot more than just using react. Eg, browserify is mentioned, but that's a totally separate project from react, completely orthogonal. So inexperience seems like a big factor here..

It's the ecosystem that's being complained about here it seems, rather than react specifically.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com