Which as someone who greatly appreciates the separation Rust offers, this makes me curious: does the string type either not enforce its contents being Unicode, or is it not capable of storing arbitrary OS paths? Because AFAICT, the two are mutually exclusive. The rub here is that OS paths — on POSIX operating systems¹ — are byte strings that we like to pretend are text; but since no particular encoding is enforced, you end up with effectively just byte strings. A String type that validates itself as valid Unicode is not capable of representing these (as arbitrary byte strings are not necessarily valid Unicode). But if we let the String type not validate, then I can pass non-Unicode to functions that take a "String" — something I'd rather not do.
There's also Python's byte smuggling, but I find that a bit weird.
¹While I call out POSIX, I'm told Window's pathnames are sequences of unsigned 16-bit values that most people expect to be UTF-16 — but that fact isn't enforced by the OS.
I don't know what happens if you do something like mount an NFS share with filenames that aren't valid Unicode. I would guess a fair amount of stuff will break.
Swift strings are Unicode, and Unicode is certainly capable of representing arbitrary byte streams, by just converting to and from any 8 bit fixed-width encoding (not UTF-8!). There are explicit conversion functions like -fileSystemRepresentation which handle the conversion between filesystem paths and Strings.
People differ on whether or not universal reference counting is a form of garbage collection with weak guarantees or a form of manual memory manage with flexible semantics.
Which is pretty unfortunate, because the memory management field has always treated reference counting as a form of garbage collection—because it is [1] [2]. The idea that reference counting is somehow not GC is as far as I can tell a recent one (popularized, I think, by Cocoa and iOS?)
This is not just a semantic quibble, because there are successful garbage collection techniques that combine tracing with reference counting (e.g. ulterior reference counting [3]) to achieve GC, so treating tracing as the only way to do GC makes no sense. In fact, David Bacon observed in 2004 that reference counting and tracing garbage collection are best viewed as just two extremes of a continuum [4], and many "optimizations" that you apply to one scheme or the other are really just moving the scheme you choose toward the opposite pole.
[1]: http://www.memorymanagement.org/glossary/g.html#term-garbage...
[2]: http://researcher.watson.ibm.com/researcher/files/us-bacon/B...
[3]: http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/mckinley/papers/urc-oopsla-20...
[4]: https://www.cs.virginia.edu/~cs415/reading/bacon-garbage.pdf
I remember seeing lots of "but Python doesn't have REAL GC" arguments years ago. But Cocoa's foray into GC, subsequent retreat back to manual ref counting and then ARC probably have affected this too, yeah.
What they miss is that RC is a form of GC algorithms and that Apple only gave up on Objective-C's GC, because they never managed to make it stable.
The way one could link GC enabled with non GC enabled frameworks, plus the fragility of underlying C code for memory management meant Apple developer forums were full of crash reports.
So Apple did a "Worse is Better" pivot and basically made the compiler automate the retain/release calls from Cocoa that were being written by hand.
Similarly Swift adopts ARC, because it needs to interoperate with Objective-C's runtime and having a GC would introduce extra performance issues, or force them to use a RC cache mechanism like .NET has for COM.
But of course, the majority without the background knowledge of how the decision came to be or interest in compiler design, just uses Apple's decision as some kind of proof against GC.
From what I can remember pauses were never an issue.
There used to exist a quite long page on the Apple Developer's web site listening all the caveats and corner cases to watch out when enabling new GC algorithm, if you will.
It is called "Garbage Collection Programming Guide", but all links to it have been disabled. But you can see get it with a bit of Google-Fu.
Also I remember to occasionally go through the forums and they had quite a few developers having integration issues with the new algorithm.