As the owner of a BMW, he's entitled to ask BMW for a copy of the LGPL source used. Job well done.
As the owner of a BMW, he's entitled to ask BMW for a copy of the LGPL source used. Job well done.
This is not true in any way - people who use and sell software, such as BMW, spend a lot of time, money, and lawyers on licensing issues.
Corporations care about anything that affects their bottom line, and a distinguished hacker who raises a small ruckus could ultimately build into disaster. It's simply responsible to have your front line know who to refer people to when they ask if you're in compliance with the law.
Do BMW have any obligation to provide it in any kind of
buildable state?
Yes. GPLv2, section 3: For an executable work, complete source
code means all the source code for all
modules it contains, plus any associated interface
definition files, plus the scripts used to control
compilation and installation of the executable.For example, perhaps they have no build scripts, and do it by hand every time.
If BMW developers do it this way, then that's fine by the wording of the GPL. It wouldn't be reasonable to require them to provide anything further than what they already do.