To me that's just analogous to the Nazis, who were neither nationalist nor socialist, or the GDR, which wasn't exactly democratic, not to mention that it's in line with titles like "Ministry of Love". It would have been kinda silly to have INGSOC call itself "thugs driven by sadomasochism" or anything else "honest": of course they have a nice name and a handshake as a symbol, while they do the exact opposite.
I don't know what Orwell thought of socialism so I'm not saying you're wrong, but that bit by itself is not a very good argument.
http://www.george-orwell.org/Down_and_Out_in_Paris_and_Londo...
This is a common problem since about the 1930s, that Communist parties were big on loyalty and short on critical thinking, tending to support Stalinism and downplay or disbelieve its totalitarianism.
I second the recommendation to read The Road To Wigan Pier.
But he fought in a Trotskyist militia. With criticisms, yes. But he took up arms with communists.
Which is why I always find it quite amusing when libertarians and conservatives use Animal Farm and 1984 as support in their arguments. Orwell would break no bread with them; he was a socialist of a revolutionary bent.
That's why he was against Communism. His experience with the Communists and with being a Communist.
There's no sense, in any of Orwell's later writing, that he renounced socialism and plenty that affirmed his socialist ideas. Orwell stated in one of those works (Why I Write, 1946), that every word he wrote since 1936 was for democratic socialism, and the ending of Animal Farm, for instance, ultimately shows the communist pigs being no different from the capitalist humans (something that the CIA latched onto when they financed the 1948 animated film version, and so they had the ending changed).