We're not talking about stub pages, it's all the fully automated bullshit that you are generating. They not only need to be deindexed, they need to be nofollowed or removed altogether.
How is it you are out there playing the wounded puppy when apparently you haven't even read the articles or followed the reference links? You can't just skim this one and then craft a rebuttal and think you've addressed the issue. There's a lot of data in those paragraphs you apparently just skimmed over (if that even).
You have over 500,000 pages listed in your xml sitemap, and Google appears to have over 330,000 of them indexed. Click on this link, please, and actually go look at 10-12 of the pages we are talking about here:
Tell me how long it takes you, just by clicking through, to find even 3 pages that have any human interaction in them whatsoever.
Maybe, just maybe, you really don't have a clue what is happening. I personally don't believe that's the case, but if so then whoever it is you have working for you that set this up knows how to spam like a pro.