As far as I can tell both places are roughly the same in demographics, education, and only recently has SF surged ahead in wealth (and SF used to be even worse than it is now.)
As far as I can tell both places are roughly the same in demographics, education, and only recently has SF surged ahead in wealth (and SF used to be even worse than it is now.)
The longer answer is complicated.
1. Some urban planning decisions are made at the state, not local, level, which means that more housing gets built and prices are lower: http://www.vox.com/2016/4/6/11370258/honan-zoning-reform-bil....
2. The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) is insane. For example, it allows anyone to sue anyone building anything on environmental grounds.
3. CA has Prop 13, which is also insane, and Prop U in LA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proposition_U which is insane. Prop U encourages some people at the margins to pick SF over LA.
4. SF has rent control, which means that many voters are encouraged to say no to everything.
5. The cities' histories are different: http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing. SF has a longer history of radical, economically illiterate politics than Seattle.
6. Seattle's city government is not quite as reasonable as it looks. Google "The Seattle Process" or Kshama Sawant. It only looks better than SF because SF has uniquely terrible voters.
Seattle has a population of 652k, with an average density of 8k/sq mi.
San Francisco has a population of 864k, with an average density of 18.5k/sq mi.
And yet:
Seattle has a jobs-to-housing ratio of 1.5
SF has a jobs-to-housing ratio of 1.6
So what explains SF's higher costs? Density coupled with massive wealth inequality. Period.
Upzoning increases land value in a tight market. Markets remain tight in desirable locations and no amount of development has been able to keep up; population is growing, job growth in the tech sector is high, and the wealth gap coupled with high demand means that there's enormous price elasticity for some, who then push the rest out.
High density construction carries a higher barrier to entry, and is almost exclusively allocated to rental units. Additionally, high density construction allows one to combine multiple profitable uses in the same plot; commercial and residential.
This accelerates the wealth divide, putting more money into the hands of fewer and fewer land owners, with rents tracking whatever the high demand is capable of sustaining. Nobody else ever builds up equity, the city winds up being owned by fewer and fewer, and the low end of the market is priced out.
This then requires attempts at government correction, through subsidized housing; either as outright grants to developers, zoning variances granted to allow higher margins in exchange for permanently affordable (but still rental!) units, tax credits, etc.
This further accelerates the growth of the wealth divide, as development and development investment companies begin to specialize in cornering access to (and brokerage of) these economic perks that are unavailable to individual potential home owners.
Density does not fix housing. It literally never has, and I do not even begin to understand how this conception became the norm amongst housing activists. As near as I call tell, it's something that's been green/liberal-washed as a necessity by those who profit the most from the government-funded development incentives.
We even stole your gold rush idea. Thanks for that. Great idea.
Basically we've been sucking you guys dry for 150 years :p