> The "American Dream" of owning a house [...], in my opinion, a waste of mindshare and money.
If we want to discuss city apartments vs suburban houses with "intellectual honesty", I would hope those in favor of downtown urban living acknowledge that some of us really do prefer living in houses.
I lived for 2 years in Chicago's downtown loop in a "nice" apartment. Yes, everything was "walking distance". I could walk to Grant Park, the lake, the museum, the restaurants. But I don't care about any of that. Even though I was on the 6th floor, I heard police sirens and taxi horns every day and never got used to it. I also spent a year consulting in downtown Manhattan and visited Tokyo,London,Paris. I can see how the vibrancy and immediacy of those cities appeal to others but they don't appeal to me.
I now live 35 miles away from downtown and the tranquility is wonderful. I can look out the window and watch squirrels and birds around the trees. Also, I can putz around my garage with noisy woodworking tools for weekend projects. I don't like the implication that my brain is somehow "broken" for not preferring city living. Many of us are not ignorant of the urban lifestyle. We tried it and we'd prefer to raise a family away from it. We will spend a big chunk of income to make that happen. It doesn't mean we're irrational or brainwashed.