The GGP highlighted both the commute and the city amenities. He specifically contrasted the house with "big backyards" vs apartment access to "Central/Riverside parks, etc"
I was countering the notion that those city amenities are so wonderful that supposedly clueless suburbanites "don't know what they're missing out on". Well, we do know what those city benefits are. We enjoyed them at one phase in our lives. We just don't prioritize them.
As for the longer commute time of suburbia... to me, it was already an underlying premise. In any case, there are also several factors affecting it. In two-income families, if one spouse works in the city, it's common for the other spouse to work outside of it. So, depending on the type of jobs the husband & wife have, they really don't reduce total commute time for the entire family unit by choosing to live in downtown. Another interesting data point is that many wealthy earners (e.g. hedge fund mgrs, etc) in NYC deliberately purchase their family homes out in the suburbs instead of a high rise apartment next to Central Park. They have the high income to live anywhere and yet they also made the "irrational" decision to commute 2 hours every day to live away from downtown.
>Is a house worth that much time? Well, it probably depends on the people.
Exactly. People prioritize different things.
I had a balcony with my nice Chicago apartment but I never used it. My ears didn't like the constant noise of traffic. On the other hand, my house has a covered outdoor area with a grill that I use all the time. It seems like people spend their "commute" time as a calculated tradeoff to enjoy a certain lifestyle away from the office.