While true on paper here's what really happens to most people:
1) They spend the extra time working instead of what they would otherwise consider family/fun/relax time.
2) If buying a place costs X and renting costs Y, they end up spending (Y-X) frivolously and getting accustomed to that level of spending.
If nothing else, owning a home tricks/forces/cajoles people into saving money. Sure you can argue, "I'll save the difference and invest it at Z% ... Win!" but that's not what the VAST majority of people will do.
If you spend 2 hours in transit... or 20 minutes. If you "invest" or "spend on frivolities"... If you use your time more productively instead of sitting on a bus/in a car...
While the trade off might not make sense to you, it obviously does make sense to the GP.
I live on family property... and it would actually cost more (no rent/mortgage... vs something new) to live close to work, but I would get ~2 hours of driving (~1 each way) if I moved closer. Due to a variety of reasons, I stay where I'm at.
Due to a variety of reasons, other people choose to move closer.
Just because they aren't super efficient (wasting money/time, as you seem to suggest), doesn't mean they aren't better off with that decision.
Having done both (short and long commutes), I'd say yes, but only in the short term. There's a distinct joy in not taking any form of powered transit to work. You feel it with every step you take walking in the mornings.
Eventually that joy wears off though as you realize that you haven't saved squat over the past N years and if that trend continues, you'll eventually get priced out of renting too!
Growing up, I lived closer to where I worked... I'd walk or bike to work. Getting older, I moved around and anything I've done in the longest time requires "long" commutes (30-60 minutes each way). I've been on both sides and am fine with either.
Given a slightly modified set of circumstances, I would probably pay a bit more to shave an hour or two off my commute... the added time and lessened stress (so many bad drivers on the roads... more time to play CoD...) would be worth it.
I am lucky enough to live on Family Property - so the economic benefits of having zero rent/mortgage can't be understated (and is a major reason I commute) but it does come at an expense in time commuting.
Homes as a trick to saving or not spending seems vacuous, it's like the enforced marriage wedding debt hyped up about a certain tribe in the phillipines. If you need to be deeply in debt to spend money wisely, something is wrong.
The GGP highlighted both the commute and the city amenities. He specifically contrasted the house with "big backyards" vs apartment access to "Central/Riverside parks, etc"
I was countering the notion that those city amenities are so wonderful that supposedly clueless suburbanites "don't know what they're missing out on". Well, we do know what those city benefits are. We enjoyed them at one phase in our lives. We just don't prioritize them.
As for the longer commute time of suburbia... to me, it was already an underlying premise. In any case, there are also several factors affecting it. In two-income families, if one spouse works in the city, it's common for the other spouse to work outside of it. So, depending on the type of jobs the husband & wife have, they really don't reduce total commute time for the entire family unit by choosing to live in downtown. Another interesting data point is that many wealthy earners (e.g. hedge fund mgrs, etc) in NYC deliberately purchase their family homes out in the suburbs instead of a high rise apartment next to Central Park. They have the high income to live anywhere and yet they also made the "irrational" decision to commute 2 hours every day to live away from downtown.
>Is a house worth that much time? Well, it probably depends on the people.
Exactly. People prioritize different things.
I had a balcony with my nice Chicago apartment but I never used it. My ears didn't like the constant noise of traffic. On the other hand, my house has a covered outdoor area with a grill that I use all the time. It seems like people spend their "commute" time as a calculated tradeoff to enjoy a certain lifestyle away from the office.
Hey, you prefer the suburbs and long commutes. Great. But neighborhoods do actually exist in a city of 3 million+. Commutes are minimal, with few taxis and sirens to rattle one prone to rattling. Let's not for a second indulge the idea that you made a fair comparison.
Chicago is large enough there are a lot of communities [1] not a central one. Depending on what you're interested there are different neighborhoods for whatever kind of lifestyle you're wanting to find yourself in and always new developing ones if you want to make your own.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_areas_in_Chicago
Fine. Then I'll try to make one. I used to live in a beautiful part of Minneapolis. A tree-lined, peaceful street near the edge of town that was so bucolic I had a friend who came to my house for over a year before she realized that I lived within the city limits, not an inner-ring suburb. I knew my neighbors, could walk to the grocery store, restaurants, movie theater and the big museums, theaters, etc were a 10 minute drive away in downtown. We went to art galleries and performances fairly regularly.
Now I live on a small farm about 40 miles outside the city. The two closest non-agricultural businesses to my home are a bar and a McDonald's. Yet I will never move back to the city; I simply prefer it here.
The problem with so many of these articles, and the resulting comments, is that everyone comes out of the woodwork claiming that their way is best and anyone who disagrees doesn't know what the other side looks like. Not so: as the GP stated, we know the pros and cons of either choice. We also know better than you what we prefer!
Not sure where you think I've claimed to know better than you or anybody on that matter.
You like long commutes and exurbs and aren't so hot on having close neighbors. Great. Call it what it is.
Probably because your replies have an undercurrent of condescension in them. Take your following comment for example:
>and whose comfort level is forever pegged to those enclaves.
This type of psychological profiling of my background to make it look like my living preferences are "defective" smacks of smug superiority.
My mother didn't buy a suburban house until I was 19 so I grew up living in apartments. And yes, I had friends in Chicago's Gold Coast and other "community" neighborhoods where you see people riding bicycles, etc. Those benefits don't tip the scales for me. It's still sharing walls and ceilings with neighbors. Yes, townhomes are less dense than apartments but it's still sharing walls. Besides, the Chicago loop was a quick 10 minute walk from the office. The Gold Coast means a 20+ minute subway ride -- and more walking after the substation. That kind of negates the convenience aspects. In any case, none of those urban environments make may say, "gosh, this apartment and community is my dream."
Here's another unproductive comment from you:
>You like long commutes
Nobody here said he "likes/enjoys/favors long commutes". Please don't put words in people's mouths to try to win an argument. The commute is a tradeoff (aka a necessary evil). It is not something we "like".
And another one:
>Again: you like suburbs
You just ignore the fact that he stated, "apartments suck and city living is overrated."
Your style of replies to everyone has that fingers-in-the-ears-I-can't-hear-you vibe to it.
I think I know better than you do what I mean with I've written, thanks.
You DO like long commutes and you DON'T like being near neighbors. Why not own it?
No, it's actually ridiculous.
Again: you like suburbs and necessarily the long commutes that go with them.