1) Hello 2) Show I read their profile. "Oh you like The Mountain Goats? I saw them when I was in Chicago last summer." 3) Ask a question about their interests. "I've been looking to take cooking classes. Any recommendations?"
I had an incredibly high response rate, 1 out of every 3 or 4.
"Looking pretty friendly with that penguin, do you guys still keep in touch?"
"Id say we should hula hoop together, but my hula hoop is in the shop. Unless you have a spare?"
If you're regularly sending opening messages more than a sentence or two long, you're probably investing way too much effort to start out.
I'm sure you can come up with all sorts of rationalizations as to why this isn't true, but accepting that you can do better is the first step to improving.
Try this - for your first message just send 'Hey I noticed your page and have a question for you' ('noticed' not 'saw', 'page' not 'profile', and 'question for you' not just 'question'). Why does this work? It makes someone curious what you noticed and what your question is while minimizing neediness, which is kryptonite to a woman's attraction. Want to really blow your mind? Create a woman's profile on whatever site you've used.
Do what you've always done, get what you've always gotten. The women that I met through sites were almost all sweet, sharp, quality people and they would all tell me how they would receive hundreds of messages.