Yep, this is a big mistake. Messages should be short and should take almost no effort to write. On OKC my success rate was very high and my initial messages were made up of 3 sentences max:
1) Hello 2) Show I read their profile. "Oh you like The Mountain Goats? I saw them when I was in Chicago last summer." 3) Ask a question about their interests. "I've been looking to take cooking classes. Any recommendations?"
I had an incredibly high response rate, 1 out of every 3 or 4.