Trust his advice at your own peril.
Trust his advice at your own peril.
We banned this account for serial trolling and detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11516860 and marked it off-topic.
Even if he's shilling for the government (stupid claim but whatever), what do they gain by him encouraging people to adopt better crypto habits?
This seemingly-baseless personal attack doesn't even pass the laugh test for me. I'd like to see some hard evidence.
What do government shills sound like? What are they trying to accomplish? How does Thomas line up with their modus operandi and/or endgame?
As someone who works heavily with appsec/crypto and has no business relationship with tptacek, it's obvious to me that his warnings are exclusively of the "don't do unnecessary things that often result in security foot-bullets" category.
What OpenSSH does right: public key pinning instead of a CA infrastructure. But then, you don't necessarily need the CA infrastructure for TLS.
Do all security researchers sound like government shills now?
It seems a lot of people don't understand that most people who have political views they don't like hold those views because they honestly believe it is best, not because of some nefarious conspiracy.
More importantly, I've yet to see any security advice from him that is in any way suspect. Strangely enough it is possible to disagree with someone about politics and still trust their technical advice when it time and time again is demonstrably sound.
Speaking for myself, his apologia of The State also irritates me quite a bit, but I try to keep my mouth shut because he contributes so much to the community.