Uh, hello? The paragraph consists entirely of "I" statements about the bad choices he made and concludes with a "We".
There's no "we" about it -- I made (make) choices to improve my financial wellbeing. If you don't, that's your problem.
Uh, hello? The paragraph consists entirely of "I" statements about the bad choices he made and concludes with a "We".
There's no "we" about it -- I made (make) choices to improve my financial wellbeing. If you don't, that's your problem.
If survey is accurate, that large of a percentage of the population means that society has a problem. That does not just impact the individuals that don't follow good financial practices when they could. So it ends up being your (people that make wise financial decisions) problem to a degree.
Just because it's 47% does not mean that the majority of those 47% are not entirely responsible for their own situation. The things people are mentioning (children's college/university, weddings, houses, cars) are completely dependent on the individual's own decisions. That people actually go into debt or spend their entire life savings on a bloody wedding of all things is certainly not indicative of a problem with society.
Nobody is forced to spend beyond their means to strive to place themselves above middle class. Spending is not justified because you fit the "middle class" demographic and should thus be entitled to "middle class things". There is no endemic here, only individuals making poor choices. There's no huge secret to stashing away some money. It's really not difficult. I can sympathize for someone making less than $50k/year who genuinely struggles with basics. The $50k/year earner who buys a new iPhone every year? Not so much. Someone making $150k/year who is unable to withdraw $2000 from their chequing account? Not a single ounce of sympathy for them. Unless one is in a truly sticky spot like having to pay ungodly amounts of money to manage a severe illness, there is no excuse other than an introspective look at one's priorities.
Society cannot be used as a scapegoat here. The system is not flawed. The way people try to position themselves at a higher level within the system than they can afford? There's the issue.
As written, when he finally gets to his own story, the negative outcomes all seem to be described as inevitable or circumstance. The alternative choices are so simplistic ("I knew how easily my girls could be marginalized in a society where nearly all the rewards go to a small, well-educated elite," "and cutting corners to turn them out faster, I knew, would be cutting off my career") that I think his argument would have been stronger with no explanations at all.
* Children going to a college of their choice
* A catered formal wedding
* Owning a home
* Choosing a career based on interests rather then financial stability
* Having a telecom connection (cable, internet, cell phone)
etc, etc...
* an expensive private college * fancy catered wedding * owning a larger home * doing a white collar flex hours fun career * having lots of telecom options that didn't even exist before.
As someone who went to private school, I can say certainly it doesn't count until you go to university. It may count somewhat in highschool, but primary/grammar school isn't quite the place to make connections that people make it out to be.