Hacker News Reader

How about this re-phrasing:

The most terrifying thing about prions is that they are infectious but not life: they can't be "killed" in the normal sense

While viruses are generally not considered to be alive, they are considered to be instances of life, aren't they?

View on HN

Of the 6 or 7 criteria biologists usually use to define life, viruses often fall short. E.g. viruses do not have their own metabolism.

Everyone has their own definition though. I remember reading a novel where life was defined simply as heredity, mutation, and adaptation. The second definition makes more sense to me, and implicitly includes viruses.

...and many viruses can't survive outside a host. Their structure can break apart. IIRC HIV is like that.

That doesn't quite capture it. There are lots of obligate parasites that aren't viruses, right?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obligate_parasite

That doesn't make them special. Fish can not survive without a host either (i.e. water).

Water is not a host in the biological sense.

It makes them special since bacteria can survive in numerous environments where viruses are destroyed.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com