That's not how I read his comments at all.
What he seems to be asking for is the ability to take the code you used to produce the pretty graphs and tables in your paper and re-run it, maybe tweak it himself and use it on a slightly different dataset. He wants to be able to see that your results extend to more than just the toy synthetic dataset you made up, and also be able to verify that some bug in your verification code didn't make the results seem more successful. Finally, he wants to be able to compare apples-to-apples by knowing all the details of your procedure that you didn't bother putting into the paper.
(Impersonal you, of course)