I listen to or read the transcripts of nearly all of them. They're full of ambiguous information and half-truths, and I take them with a grain of salt. This is a classic example; we have a deadline that's not really a deadline. Tesla wants this stuff to be news.
>an inevitable few of the thousands of needed parts have delays.
Is this inevitable? Does it happen to other manufacturers, who, according to critics, are building far more complex vehicles?
>this article makes me facepalm.
You don't facepalm at gems like this:
UBS Analyst: "And any color when you think about the $190 per kilowatt hour, how much like a CAGR of decline until the Gigafactory is open, another 30% once that's on line?"
Elon Musk: "Yeah, next question."
So the guy wanted to know how Tesla plans on benefitting from the scale and battery efficiency of the Gigafactory production (originally planned for 2020) if they're moving up the production timetable. In other words, how much is that going to affect the cost of Model 3 production? You don't think that's a valid question?
Then the guy basically asks the EXACT same thing, but rather than asking for the final price, he asked for the pace of reduction (CAGR) in price, over a given amount of time (until the Gigafactory is open, and once it is online)... which would allow him to calculate cost/kwh when Model 3 launches.
Musk politely answered a whole series of questions from this and other analysts, only cutting them off if they asked something stupid - like this guy. You're not gonna trick Elon Musk into giving you more data by asking the question a different way.
What is "proprietary" about it? Previous plans and costing were based on the Gigafactory being able to achieve scale by 2020. That production is being bumped forward two years, so what effect will it have on costs? Why would we assume they can suddenly get the same savings in less time? It's a good question from an investor's perspective.
>Musk politely answered a whole series of questions from this and other analysts
Yeah, he loves answering Adam Jonas. Many of these guys are practically shills. Some of their questions are embarrassing.
>You're not gonna trick Elon Musk into giving you more data by asking the question a different way.
Here's the thing HN doesn't seem to get: this is a public company. People have the right to ask questions. In fact, more questions should be asked of companies like this, that are losing vast sums of money yet have sky-high valuations. That's the difference between genuinely curious people and those who are willing to take what the CEO says at his word, for everything.
Watch for an equity offering soon, something else that we were told wouldn't happen.
He did ask the question. You have the right to ask questions of a private company too. And both private and public companies have the right not to answer. Everything they're required to make public is already in the filings. You seem to be indicating that they're required to say more, but they're not.
We never really know that, ex ante. Everyone looks like they're reporting what they need to, until we find out they aren't. That's the point of asking questions.
But it isn't about requirements. It's a valid question, that was sidestepped by Musk (and here, apparently). Here it is for posterity: the pricing for the Model 3 was based on achieving scale and efficiency in battery production from the Gigafactory. With production bumped up two years, what effect will that have on pricing? If it's none, how is that achieved?
EDIT: as for other manufacturers, I have no idea, but the question is more whether they talk about their internal target dates at all. Elon never said that production actually would start on July 1 (but more like "before end of 2017"), so calling this a "delay" is just wrong.
You seem to be confused about what "factored in" means:
>it will then take some number of months
How many months? That's "factoring it in". "Some months" provides zero information.
>so calling this a "delay" is just wrong.
Of course there's no delay yet, it's all just talk. I think it's people planning for the inevitable delay, based on historical manufacturing results and this nebulous fudge factor.
The big news is the call of 500k cars by 2018 (100k-200k in 2017). If they can pull that off it's insane.
>their internal target dates at all
Again, who cares about some random internal date that may be off by some unknown number of months? What information do we glean from it? It's nigh useless.
And other manufacturers are far more transparent about their actual financial and production information.
EDIT: If you do add a bunch of stuff to your comments after the fact, it'd be nice to put an EDIT marker somewhere at least.
I added a couple lines and fixed typos, within minutes of posting. Maybe you could mellow out and not feel like you need to reply instantaneously? The Tesla fans are touchy today...