Polymer is made of magic. It uses magic cutting-edge browser features where available, and where they aren't it fakes them using magic. Some of its APIs like Polymer.dom(x) are completely magic. When it works, it works really well. When it doesn't you are going to waste so much time trying to find out why.
It also assumes that everything you're doing is through Polymer; so you won't get much mileage out of, say, JQuery. While it admits the existence of other Javascript libraries it tends to blank them at parties.
If I were to do my current project again... I'd probably still choose Polymer, although I'd take another look at the other Javascript UI toolkits. Web components are so, so nice for designing UIs --- I can finally use actual computer science techniques like abstraction and modularity for building UIs! --- and it's got the best consistent look and feel that I've ever seen in a Javascript UI toolkit.