It sounds like this is a problem with badly-engineered consumption tax, not consumption tax itself.
I generally agree with your proposals. However, I don't think all forms of "social engineering" are bad. We need to make the best possible statement about ourselves as a society and what our values are, and that means cracking down on the tumors. If our rich want to behave like uncultured oil sheikhs, they can move to the desert, give up their US citizenship, and act like assholes all they want; but as long as they're in America, they'll behave themselves.
The US has a problem with cultural inversion: the people at the very top of society (George W. Bush, Paris Hilton) are uncultured, mouth-breathing trashbag-fuckers, while (on the inverse) it seems like everyone must know at least one brilliant, cultured, educated people who are struggling to pay rent. This is a morale killer. It also ripples through society; the reason we have a "next-quarter" mentality in business and no universal healthcare is that uncultured trash-fuckers have too much money and power. We've got to do something about it, and preferably now while it can still be relatively legal and bloodless. I think a targeted consumption tax is great because it is completely bloodless.
[* "everyone knows" clause in last paragraph edited for correctness]