Not dubious, tor is used by all sorts of abusive spam bots and people who just want to shitpost for the lulz.
Obviously every service has different trade-offs to consider, which is why "Tor traffic is always worth it" is HN comment idealism.
How do you differentiate between legitimate new users with a bunch of existing users vouching for them, and a returning shitposter's 10000th spam account with a bunch of existing stealth-mode accounts vouching for them?
I think you're using an extremely weak definition of "solve".