When you are covering a story where there are conflicting views, it is not nice to pick one side and see the opposing view as an illness that needs to be treated. It is just not right, no matter how absurd the opposing view sounds to you.
When you are covering a story where there are conflicting views, it is not nice to pick one side and see the opposing view as an illness that needs to be treated. It is just not right, no matter how absurd the opposing view sounds to you.
Someone is always going to disagree and trying to accommodate extreme fringe beliefs basically prevents you from communicating accurately. Worse it adds a fake air of legitimacy to every wack-job out there.
It's not about creating a numerical balance between groups of people with differing views, it's about refining an idea by challenging it. If those 10 people really are wrong then the evidence will dismiss their point immediately and you have nothing to worry about.
Presenting an idea without challenging it, or worse challenging it with straw man, makes your work less persuasive.
That is just a small illustration of how your truth may not the universal truth for all.
Here is how I would outline this article:
- There is this group of people who shares the same idea who are thought to be crazy. (Intro)
- They have attracted some attention and grown in numbers recently. (Background)
- Medical experts who study them think they are delusional. (Mainstream view)
- This group of people denies such claims and provide personal recounts. (Alternative view)
The violent part is only boarder line related to the main issue as it was an exception. So it should only be briefly mentioned, instead of being given an entire section.
10 million who are not involved in the slightest and would not even know about this without seeing it in the news.
So your argument is, since x billion (not just million) people don't know something we can already conclude it doesn't exist.
I'm attacking your numbers argument, nothing else.
And your "someone will always disagree" is completely out of place - it's true about about something not present in this story at all. So by throwing in some random true fact you made your 2nd argument.
Last, the comparison with "climate deniers" (others in this thread) is bogus too: The difference is that topic was WAS discussed at great length - and the "deniers" did get heard. So yes, after hearing all sides there is no need to give everyone equal time. In this story however we hear about it for the very first time, and while I certainly don't expect to give them equal time for their views, and personally would not bother one iota, it makes me wonder:
What happens when we hear such stories and always automatically assume they are wrong? For me it's not about this one single story, but how we handle such stories in general. Always throwing the "majority opinion" view around seems misguided. I'm not much concerned about this particular case, but about the generalities thrown around here like the the "10 million people" argument above. Just because those people are sick doesn't make your justification/reasoning correct - somebody else being wrong doesn't make you right automatically!
"Most people don't believe this" is a pretty poor standard for evidence. "No logical reason for these particular people to be stalked has been identified, the only people that believe this activity is actually taking place appear to be those claiming to actually suffer from it; experts in mental illness who have studied some of the individuals claiming to experience the phenomena note that they are exhibiting well-established symptoms of mental illnesses" is a pretty good standard of evidence.
Unlike most almost-certainly-incorrect beliefs, it also appears that those who come to adopt this one genuinely suffer from it, so I'm not even convinced the assumption that we should consider it pretty plausible and encourage both sides of the argument to publicise their case would be a benign one. (A corollary of this is that even in the staggeringly unlikely event that independent evidence can be found that some shadowy group actually is attempting to unsettle a particular individual by sending out minions to gas stations to mimic their actions, they'd probably feel even more intimidated for receiving that confirmation)
The controversy only exists in the mind of that minority, and their extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof (Thanks, Carl Sagan) - the birthers, climate change deniers, creationists trump supporters and spoon benders fail to meet the minimum criteria, but their bombastic temperaments make for good press coverage, which keeps them in the headlines and in our collective consciousness.
Equal time? No. Should it be discussed? Absolutely yes.
Creationism has no more validity than any other creation myth. It should be dismissed from science as readily as Zeus, Ra, or Xenu.
The appropriate place to study mythology is in a mythology class - until and unless that mythology offers falsifiable evidence to support moving it into the sphere of reality.
Otherwise, to write a report about a subject where supposedly there is already an overwhelming agreement seems a waste of time. Who would you be trying to convince?
Some quotes that reveals the author's view:
"For the few specialists who have looked closely, these individuals represent an alarming development in the history of mental illness: thousands of sick people, banded together and demanding recognition on the basis of shared paranoias."
"The vast majority of people with psychosis never resort to violence. Still, studies suggest that a small number of those experiencing psychotic episodes — especially paranoid thoughts, accompanied by voices making commands — are more likely to act on hostile urges than people without a mental illness."
"The big hope is that society will wake up to what’s happening and put a stop to it, those who feel targeted say. In some cases, they do seek psychiatric help. In others, the delusions subside. For the rest, the prognosis isn’t good, psychiatrists say. Many contemplate suicide."
"One thing he is certain of though, he says: He’s not crazy."