I don't know if people will ever stumble upon a set of interaction constraints that will make people civil if they're not already committed to civility. In that regard HN has always been good (but not perfect, as evidenced by some of the episodes mentioned in this comment section).
If someone lashes out and gets a calm response instead of being downvoted to oblivion or without being baited, the whole atmosphere becomes much less toxic (even if the original commenter insists on trolling).