Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by dmuth | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

dmuth

So it's like DNS for GPS coordinates. Neat!

View on HN

Yes, except unlike DNS, it's centralized into a single database and you may have to pay a license fee to read from it.

It can't be that hard to reverse engineer the algorithm, can it?

It's not hard, but it's unsurprisingly against the ToS (http://developer.what3words.com/api/licence/)

"You shall not use the API for any application that replicates or attempts to replace the essential user experience of the Service or use the API to create a Product which functions substantially the same as the API and offer it for use by third parties. You must not pre-fetch, cache, index, copy, re-utilise, extract or store any what3words Data"

Anyone in Somalia want to scrape the DB?

That only mentions using their API, not reverse engineering the algorithm.

... which is patented (see the other thread), so you're opening a whole another can of worms that frankly doesn't sound much better.

You pay for domains so it's not all that different.

No! You pay only to register, but reading is free.

what's the difference? On DNS you pay for the "writes" so DNS is not free either.

What3Words is free for writes (presumably it's generated from an algorithm and there aren't really "writes") and you pay for reads.

Kind of a big difference. With DNS you only have to pay if you want a domain. I can freely do a DNS query to resolve "flamingmongoosefarts.com", but with What3Words I (might not) be able to freely determine where flaming.mongoose.farts is.

DNS query is free because someone pays for the domain registration and your DNS queries(DNS queries/servers cost too). I can see how What3Words could charge the address owner a fee for its address to be licensed publicly just like the domain registration publishes your NS records as long as the maintenance fee is paid. Tbh I must admit that they are slightly different scenarios because the domain name registration is slightly distributed but my point is that public DNS/Domain registration is neither free nor open. They are controlled by various entities/corporations so they are not the best examples.

you do not pay for dns queries

You still pay for writes(i.e. domain registration). You can argue that DNS and domain registration are different things but in reallity they are inter-dependent so there is still a cost and the system is "owned" by several entities(i.e. ICANN)

that didnt dawn on me until you said it... quite the catch.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com