Huh. Have you spent any time typing on one of the new keyboards? I have, a bit, and I find it so awful that it's genuinely a complete dealbreaker as far as buying any laptop with it.
I have, and I like them. They're extremely crisp. You know exactly when they've been actuated, and they don't "roll" in the corners. I've got a very light touch so the lack of travel doesn't bother me.