However, Apple clearly should be able to require a fee for providing the marketplace and payment framework, and you can see their point in not wanting apps to circumvent that to make it simpler for users to be able to manage their subscriptions easily.
Some kind of cap and/or transaction fee seems more reasonable and would be win-win in the long run. You get a bad taste in your mouth when it feels like Apple is using their walled garden to strong arm competition. You can't compete when your largest rival eliminates your profits.
In the end I think it's to Apple's detriment to play aggressively with content providers in their ecosystem when they're in such fierce competition with Android.