The ENTIRE POINT of the paper is that there are inappropriate assumptions baked into the defaults of FSL and SPM. (AFNI has an actual code-does-the-wrong-thing bug). These errors result in cluster-wise tests being inappropriately sized: when thresholds are set to p<0.001, there are more than 0.1% false positives.
They tested this by dividing a single stream of "off" data into segments of "ON" and "OFF" data. They do this in four different ways (two block paradigms and two event-related paradigms). Most fMRI experiments use a paradigm that is close to one of these, so this isn't a fishing attempt--it's meant to make the results broadly applicable .
They argue that, by construction, no ON data is present in this pseudo-data. Therefore, any ON calls must be spurious/false alarms/type I errors/etc, which lets you calculate the actual FWER and compare it with its nominal size.
You seem to be arguing that this step is not true--some other assumption, which they knew about(?), causes it. The NeuroImage paper says that different assumed activity paradigms have different false positive rates because the assumed model is dumb. The event-related paradigms alternate between on and off rapidly (and at random), which washes out the effects of unmodelled low frequencies. The much slower block designs, on the other hand, are especially susceptible to this problem because they spend a long time in each condition.
The current work extends that to look at other ways in which the default assumptions might be dumb in SPM, while adding in more data, different tests, and other packages.
I am open to the argument that the Block Design data (e.g., in Figure 2 in PNAS) does not add much because the NeuroImage paper already suggests those designs are screwed. However, it also says that the event-related designs are actually in pretty good shape: the voxel-based familywise error rates in the NeuroImage paper are about right (Figure 2), but the cluster FWER for the same design is through the roof in the PNAS paper.
Otherwise though, I don't see many unwarranted/undiscussed assumptions in the paper. If you want to keep claiming that the authors (and I) are making wild assumptions, it would be nice to have a vague sense of what they are and why they/I am wrong.