They like to call it Disruptive Innovation or some other fancy term.
The problem with Uber is they think every country is the same and welcomes them. I under that might be the case with U.S, but it doesn't mean taxi system in every country is broken and they are welcomed to "fix it".
I don't know that that's the case. In other places, it seems to manage to be net good for the customers, good for society, and mostly only bad for existing taxi companies. But "people are using Uber" is far from sufficient evidence to say that taxis are crap.
Uber moves all these responsibilities to the owner of the car, now you are your own business man you face the majority of risks and Uber still gets a big chunk of profit. Uber doesn't care about your maintenance costs.
Sometimes it works, often this encourages dangerous behavior to still have profits e.g. skipping maintenance, safe working times, vacation... Uber doesn't care that much about this. A lot of people work almost full time without enough compensation to warrant the stress.
Besides that European countries - at least the bigger cities - have often excellent public transport that is inexpensive and mostly works. Taxis supplement that and Uber is trying to compete on price there, something that abuses the drivers in the long run.
I hope Uber is kept out of Europe or is regulated to protect the drivers and users.
The are less likely to rip you off, easier to catch (just press a button), to keep a record on for reimbursements, to pay (by cc), etc.
In Germany all this is provided by regular taxi services.
Assuming I take an Uber, exactly what costs are paid for by someone other than myself, the driver and Uber?
It's not Uber who's providing the knowledge, but Google or whatever (freely available) mapping backend the drivers / Uber App use.
> requires maintenance of cars
Do they require it, or do they "require" it like proper insurance?
> Assuming I take an Uber, exactly what costs are paid for by someone other than myself, the driver and Uber?
The risk of uninsured driver getting himself (and you) in an accident in an improperly maintained car.
Secondary costs of disruption (the negative kind) of transportation market due to one player outcompeting other by acting illegally and getting away with it.
Destruction of provisions for those "worse off" in said market - i.e. it's fine if you're young and live in the middle of the city, but try getting an Uber as a grandma living on the outskirts. Drivers will refuse such unprofitable rides.
Weakening of social trust in rule of law as a successful business keeps being successful by ignoring the law and attracts copycat (you could say the authorities are to blame for not reacting swiftly enough, but then again you need a criminal doing crime to show inadequacy of the law).
This is circular logic. Your only argument seems to be that uber may not actually require insurance. That may be true, but it's also easy to fix.
>try getting an Uber as a grandma living on the outskirts
Where I live (Warsaw), they just introduced a "leaving the city" fee, which means the drivers are incentivised to take those trips. And it still probably comes out about as much as a taxi.
Uber pays a significant amount of licensing fees to Google for use of it's data. Further - Why would making use of a freely available mapping backend be 'socializing the cost' in a way that is unfair competition to taxis?
Taxis refuse unprofitable rides. Uber hides your destination until the driver picks you up, and keeps track of drivers that cancel. Ever tried to get a taxi in the slums? Wasn't possible before Uber. Ever try to get a taxi as a black man? Was pretty hard. Uber is imperfect, and your questions of how good their insurance is are valid, but everything else you've pointed out is a problem that the Taxis had, generally worse, not one that is new to uber.
Yes, Uber does pay other third parties for services. That's not socializing the costs. Similarly, a bar paying Kingfisher to manufacture beer is not "socializing the costs" of providing me with entertainment.
Do they require it, or do they "require" it like proper insurance?
I've only used Uber across 3 separate continents, but I've never rode a poorly maintained Uber.
Also, even if they didn't, this isn't "socializing the costs". The cost of poor maintenance is born by the driver and the passenger.
Destruction of provisions for those "worse off" in said market - i.e. it's fine if you're young and live in the middle of the city, but try getting an Uber as a grandma living on the outskirts.
That's not "socializing the costs". At most, that's privatizing something that you would prefer to be surreptitiously socialized. Also, Uber makes it easier rather than harder for said Grandma to get a ride.
As for "Weakening of social trust in rule of law", many things do this. For example, black Americans and others violating unjust laws as part of civil disobedience has the same effect. Is protecting respect for the law truly an important value when the underlying law is unjust?
This should be addressed regardless of Uber's existence. In Poland we have an Insurance Guarantee Fund (Ubezpieczeniowy Fundusz Gwarancyjny[1]), an institution which pays out judgements to people harmed by drivers without proper insurance.
[1] https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ubezpieczeniowy_Fundusz_Gwaran...
(I'm providing context, not wishing to engage in political conversation)
I think Uber made a judgement call that the Hungarian government would likely enforce the laws rather harshly, and did not want to deal with the consequences.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_border_barrier
[2] https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-press/2015/hungary
The taxi drivers who remained in business were in for the trade-off of investing into compliance with new regulation but making more money than before. So old school taxi was not simply lingering in its naturally backward state as in other countries, but there was an artificially fortified status quo.
In that situation, when value personal transfer reappeared with Uber, it was therefore even more sore for the taxi companies and drivers, who took their position and the protection of their investment granted by the state. So what happened is nothing else just the taxi maffia enforced this grant and the state complied. Both sticking to decisions that once made (no regard of consequences), and heavy state control is quite to the taste of the government -- thus they complied happily.
And once the government puts its weight into something, there is no question it's gonna happen. The only surprise element is that Uber resisted so far.
uber is just pirate taxi with nice website.
I believe they will prevail in the end.