> The mammoth process involved three extra rounds of peer-review and four new peer-reviewers. From the original submission on 3 November, 2011, to the paper’s re-acceptance on 26 April, 2016, the manuscript was reviewed by seven reviewers and two editors, underwent nine rounds of revisions, and was assessed a total of 21 times – not to mention the countless rounds of internal revisions made by our research team and data contributors. One reviewer even commented that we had done “a commendable, perhaps bordering on an insane, amount of work”.
So one side you do this "mammoth" and "insane" task to review paper. On other side you block people from doing independent audit?
Climate studies decide how billions (if not trillions) of dollars are spend. People should be allowed to cross examine raw data and program source code.