There is a more general issue in science or any data-intensive practice (Google ranking is another example) where the argument “People should be allowed to cross examine raw data” fails to acknowledge that ‘People’ generally do not have the ability or know-how to, and those who can generally have interested financial backing. In many cases, it is positive (Open Source Map is a good example of that: my employer is interested in identifying, say, bike parking spots) but there are examples where de-anonymisation, competitive pressure, make “sharing data” a pragmatic question that needs more than principles.
Will more people who can contribute positively to climate science help if they had free access to those data? It is the case for astronomy; I am less convinced for climate science.