Climate science is way more important than astronomy. It should have much higher standards for transparency, not other way around.
Climate science is way more important than astronomy. It should have much higher standards for transparency, not other way around.
> It should have much higher standards
Yes, but for the quality of the result, not intuitions set-up as principles to replace the real pillars of science: experimentation and peer-review. Transparency is only useful if it helps getting peers; in this case, there are well documented reasons to doubt it, and that the people benefiting from that transparency are not just enemies of science, but of humanity.
While I agree that this is a problem in the current copyright law, there is still a way for researchers to "circumvent" this copyright restriction without violating the scientific principle of independent verifiability that I outlined in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12099720:
Let's say that the data is generally distributed by the owner in a standard format, say, a zip archive, which we will name foo.zip here (for simplicity). If you can't distribute the data itself, you write into your research paper a short explanation of the license terms that disallow the distribution of foo.zip. But you also add a notice what the SHA256 sum of foo.zip is. If some person who has also access to the data (say, from another university) has interest that the research result can be checked independently, they will leak foo.zip somewhere (I can imagine that sci-hub would be willing to provide server space for this).
This way access for independent verifiers can be "assured" without the original researchers having to violate copyright law.
Give that, what role does copyright law play (at least in the US) in preventing data sharing? I thought it was limited based on patient confidentiality, collaborator agreements, end-user agreements, desire to maximize publications from the same data, and other non-copyright issues which were at play.
([1] Other countries are more restrictive than the US in this regard.)
It is not paranoid, it isn't even secret.
Koch Brothers Exxon Heritage Foundation
are just 3 examples. It is absolutely within the purview of science to consider these things, as is anything. You can't just declare it off limits. We observe and have records of these groups paying people to write fake sciency-sounding reports on climate science constantly.