Hacker News Reader

Comment by karma_vaccum123 | Hacker News Reader

I am Jack's middlebrow dismissal. Why not just type "pffft" and save us the tedium of pouring through your "references"? This is every comment you post.

View on HN

Personal attacks are not allowed here. Please don't do this again.

We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12194564 and marked it off-topic.

Because we care about rigor and accuracy in this forum, and would prefer to be aware if and how the article title and content don't reflect reality. If these comments bore you, skip them.

There is nothing rigorous about the ongoing fantasy that random HN commenters know things that no one else does.

I have regularly found that random HN commenters often turn out to have years of professional experience in the industries they are commenting on. Its one of the fun parts of reading HN.

But it'd be great to have an "ignore user" function for those few who just google their skepticism.

You might want to get the "Hacker News Enhancement Suite" extension. It's incredibly useful for cases like this, for instance I have tagged Animats (the creator of this sub thread) as "faux expert" after reading some of his crypto posts (a topic I know something about) that were written as if he was an expert, but completely and dangerously wrong.

Not knowing anything about chemistry, I would've been inclined to believe his post if it wasn't for the Hacker News extension suite, and I can read from someone who actually knows the field

If their recently-googled skepticism is accurate, then I don't care how cursory it is - it saves me the five minutes of looking up the same sources myself.

That observation is circular and incredibly dangerous, though, for self-evident reasons including this thread.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com