Many of us are also very invested in this site, and are interested in keeping it close to its roots. That's why there's been a lot of alarm regarding the content on the site. I'm sure that some of it will blow over. Some of it will cause changes.
I don't really think that people are trying to get PG to automagically fix the problem for us. I think that we're trying to have an open discussion about solving the Eternal September problem with social sites. This is a recurring problem that occurs on pretty much any site that has a user-contributed component and gets popular.
And, regarding earning karma points: If you take a look at the people frequently involved in the discussion on fluff, trolls and quality slides, I think that you'll find that many of the people that are concerned about this are actually quite active on the leader board. I think it's because we're on the leader board, that we're so invested in keeping Hacker News on the straight and narrow. We've invested a lot of time and effort into the site, and are willing to continue that investment.