Does that mean the paper files can't be sorted alphabetically by name?
Does it exclude more complex paper-based search systems, like needle-sorted edge-notched cards?
Or does it only refer to computer databases?
Does that mean the paper files can't be sorted alphabetically by name?
Does it exclude more complex paper-based search systems, like needle-sorted edge-notched cards?
Or does it only refer to computer databases?
However, I'm not an American so I wouldn't presume to tell you what to do with your own country. You're welcome! /s
But at what point does it become a database and searchable, does he have to deliberately pile up the boxes of receipts higgledy-piggledy lest they accidentally fall into some sort of organised and therefore searchable order? Seems crazily broad, no?
Edited to Add: Wow, form 4473 doesn't get sent to any kind of centralised place until the gun shop that sold the particular con goes out of business. So this to my mind means a family gun business this been open for 100 years has every 4473 form they've ever written since the law came in, am I reading that right? Surely that can't be right? As in not correct, I don't mean morally, I mean that's just crazy to have a central database that doesn't centralise regularly.
Personally I think the 4473s should be destroyed after a reasonable time, and never subject to bulk capture. It's no business of the government's what purchases I make.
In all those countries with stricter gun laws, how many more times are those defenseless grandmothers been assaulted than in the US? I believe it's a fraction, perhaps even a small fraction.
In the US, how many times has a child picked up a gun and killed someone by accident? More times than grandmothers have defended themselves, or less?
How many times has a police officer shot someone for worries that the officer's own life was in danger of being shot, only to find that the person had no weapon?
How many times have SWAT and no-knock warrants been justified for worries that the person being served might be armed? And of those, how many people have died? And how many died when the police went to the wrong house?
How come having a gun didn't help Clarence Daniels keep from being assaulted by Michael Foster? http://www.motherjones.com/mixed-media/2015/01/black-man-gun...
Regarding your last sentence, I think real estate titles have shown some of the advantages to having the government track who has purchased a piece of property, so I disagree with your blanket statement.
Easily less, there are only ~600 accidental firearms fatalities a year, and we managed to get that number down from ~800 in 1980 in a period when both the population and and the number of guns it owns have increased by very roughly 50%.
Those warrior cops you cite two examples of? We still had a huge gun owning population back when they were peace officers, it's not guns per se that have resulted in that change.
Real estate titles are a very different thing, I submit to you, in that trying to take someone else's land has a much longer and greater pedigree than their weapons, and for entirely different motives.
I believe the higher number includes grandmothers who defended herself with a weapon without firing it, in which case the balance has to include all crimes which were committed with a gun.
Really I'm annoyed with kabdib for using a hypothetical scenario to justify personal gun ownership, when for decades everyone has pointed out how meaningless such scenarios are for meaningful policy change.
I never said it was "guns per se". I'm well aware of countries like Switzerland and Finland with a high gun ownership, though not as high as the US, and don't have the same sorts of gun-related violence.
I agree that real estate and vehicle titles are different things. My point was that I disagreed with the blanket statement "It's no business of the government's what purchases I make."
Substitute "aged grandma" with "anyone weaker than an attacker" being able to successfully make themselves an unattractive target, and it's going to be a pretty significant number. Figures are debated on both sides.
Real-estate titles appear to be more about taxation and revenue generation than anything else. Take away that incentive and you'll find governments doing a crappy job of it.
Since the law have been set up to prohibit the government from gathering that information, of course it's uncertain - the law was designed so there's a grey area. So, since you don't have numbers (which is why you propose the scenario instead), what about answer the question which isn't subject to statistics gathering?
How come having a gun didn't help Clarence Daniels keep from being assaulted by Michael Foster?
Second, is anyone on my side arguing guns are a panacea to all self-defense problems and situations? As it was, Daniels got roughed up, Foster was found guilty of battery, the system worked pretty well, didn't it?
You started by saying the grandmother needed it to defend herself against assault. I gave an example of an assault where a weapon proved worse than useless.
You did not say the grandmother needed it to defend herself against manslaughter or attempted manslaughter, which is what it would have been had the level of force risen to lethal.
You said a weapon was useful so ""anyone weaker than an attacker" being able to successfully make themselves an unattractive target." Yet here was a case where the presence of a gun made the victim an attractive target for assault.
In short, I said nothing that you said I said...
I commented on the assault on Clarence Daniels simply because it made a big stir in RKBA circles and therefore I know a fair amount about it, and I felt you were misrepresenting its lessons, as well as possibly the law.
And misinformation on when you're allowed to use lethal force is downright dangerous, although this case is relatively close to the threshold, depending on how effective the perpetrator's choke-hold was (it was said to be not very good). I also presume this 62 year old man was a lot more fit and strong than an "80-year-old grandmother" (especially having watched my parents make the transition from late '60s to early '80s or thereabouts in the last dozen years, kinda scary).
The Firearm Owners Protection Act, this referenced part: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firearm_Owners_Protection_Act#...
(Speaking of which, sorting machines and punched card I/O is an active hobby market. Apparently many people are looking for IBM punched cards. I think there's enough of a market should a small paper company want to sell them again.)