I'm not sure what the best way to judge that is. https://www.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=South%20par...
I'm not sure what the best way to judge that is. https://www.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=South%20par...
It's also turning into a pretty good IP to mine. I'm really looking forward to the sequel to The Stick of Truth this Christmas.
Compare "South Park" to shows that have really jumped the shark like "The Simpsons".
I don't think South Park meets either of these criteria anymore. It's not a pop culture locus like it used to be, and even their controversial episodes are ignored. Part of this isn't their fault- it's probably the continued fractalization of culture where we have ever-fewer shared experiences- but I also think it's hard to keep anything fresh for 20 years, especially something trying to be "edgy".
Note that that doesn't make it "bad", and it doesn't mean you can't still like it. But I think "coolness" can only be defined in terms of broad opinion.
Which made South Park better. Fart jokes or making fun of Canadians was never funny. They still do that but putting the finger where it hurts and calling out a political camp that is not used to be challenged is refreshing. Of course there are things they won't do, for their own safety... because some would resort to violence and directly attack South Park creators.
There was toilet/uncouth humor then along side political/social commentary, and there is basically the same product now.
My favourite seasons have to be 4-9 for this reason,