2013 5.3
2012 17.8
2011 -2.3
2010 21.8
2009 38.4
2008 -43.0
2007 1.0
2006 14.6
2005 16.0
2004 27.1
2003 102.6
2002 -35.0
2001 11.2
2000 2.2
1999 19.1
1998 -0.1
1997 -15.5
1996 44.8
1995 56.4
1994 77.9
1993 -13.7
1992 35.6
You started in 2003, and dropped it sometime after 2008. The average for 2010 through 2013 is 10.6% per year, which is OK, but I think is in line with the broad market index.
One of the recent Hulberts has a recent semilog plot of the newsletter's returns, and by I eyeballing it can see that, while it outpaced the market from 2000 to 2007, it has pretty much tracked the market since 2008. So it hasn't beaten the index lately.
Hulbert also reports that the newsletter's author prior to 2002 (when he died) used margin to augment the returns. Since 2002 another person is picking the stocks, and they're not using margin, so that might account for the recent pedestrian returns. 10% is nice, but I agree it's not spectacular.
Looking at recent behavior dissuaded me from following it. I wanted a bit more money from my investments. But I can see how, in 2003, the previous decade made the plan look really good to you. I would have done the same thing as you.