The problem is that the main true benefit of the information is to exclude people, but that isn't how people use it.
Suppose there are 2 million people in an area and you know some demographic information about the perpetrator that will allow 95% of them to be excluded. That is useful information.
But the probability that a random person in the relevant demographic is the perpetrator is now 0.001%. The demographic contains 100,000 people and one perpetrator.
The fallacy is in assuming that just because not being in the relevant demographic is enough to exclude you, that being in the relevant demographic should by itself be enough to suspect you.