Zero knowledge has a very specific meaning inside cryptography. Encrypting something does not make it "zero knowledge".
Zero knowledge has a very specific meaning inside cryptography. Encrypting something does not make it "zero knowledge".
Note that in the domain of privacy-enhancing technologies the term "zero-knowledge" does not refer to "semantically secure encryption". Instead it is used to mean that a service provider does not have access to user data, and that this claim can be proven cryptographically. The use of the term zero-knowledge to promote privacy-respecting services dates back to at least 1997 with the founding of the Canadian company Zero-Knowledge Systems [1], which provided anonymous communication services [2].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_Knowledge_Systems [2] http://edition.cnn.com/TECH/computing/9902/11/browsanon.idg/
Having said that, I agree with the point that nowadays this usage may be unhelpful in promoting privacy-respecting services because zero-knowledge proofs have come a long way and there are now services like Zerocash that actually make use of them. So using the term to promote a different privacy-respecting feature may be confusing or misleading.
[1]: https://github.com/xwiki-labs/cryptpad/graphs/contributors [2]: http://martinfowler.com/bliki/TwoHardThings.html
I have a hard time even accepting this definition of "zero knowledge' on its own, separate from the existing cryptographic one. Wouldn't the host at least know things like the size of the encrypted data? Time it was sent? Etc.
> we know nothing about the encrypted data you store on our servers
misleading, since they do know some things about the encrypted data.
https://spideroak.com/features/zero-knowledge
It's true that it doesn't match the technical meaning of zero knowledge from cryptography (although maybe arguably the meaning of the technical term could be extended to this situation in a trivial way: rather than a proof or protocol involving Bob from which Bob doesn't learn certain information, this is a protocol not involving Bob from which Bob also doesn't learn certain information).
Summary: zero-knowledge applies to authentication protocols, not encryption protocols.
We already have one or more of:
- Confidential
- End-to-end encrypted (contrasted with, but often in addition to,
transport-layer encryption)
- Privacy-preserving
- Least authority (with respect to the service operator)
- Peer-to-peer privacy
I'm one degree of separation from several SpiderOak engineers and think highly of them overall. However, this choice of marketing copy is one point we vehemently disagree on.Okay, I'd really like to hear the argument about why muddying the waters about an already-hard-to-understand subject is totally fine.
> and it's probably time I made a post about it.
Please do.
A blog post that I linked elsewhere in this thread makes the case for why it's harmful.