> Buckley was not a political thinker.
No true Scotsman.
> He was a narrow-minded ideologue
Ad hominem.
> used every rhetorical flourish
Compliment.
> doctrinaire positions
Sesquipedalian.
> never acknowledged that his opponents' positions had any value whatsoever
Simply inaccurate.
This is really what prompted the response, you can easily find examples of him conceding points to his opponents online.
In his discussions with Hitchens, the default mode is for both participants to bounce between encyclopedic historical/geographical trivia and playfully needling one another. However there are moments where each will say that the other has made an interesting point and carry it forward further. 21:30 here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AeGKcX-JHNE Earlier and later in the piece Buckley ganged up with Hitchens against Tyrell.
Most of Buckley's opinions are really dated, stuck in a version of Cold War politics that is nearly incomprehensible today, so I'm not trying to endorse his conclusions.
But he is one of the few people I've ever seen on television that has actually waited to hear what the other person says, even rephrasing it to make sure he's clear on their exact arguments before responding. That sort of patience has become a unicorn in entertainment today.
Sometimes his conversations flew off the rails, but he pulled off good conversations from time to time with people he deeply disagreed with.
Maher desperately tries to have difficult conversations, and sometimes succeeds, but it's like he's got a 30 second shot clock above the cameras measuring how often they need to slip in a punchy zinger and change the subject.
Real disagreements are just damn hard to capture on television with the attention span of most audiences. Mostly we just ended up with people shouting over each other. After watching talking heads shows today, going back and watching Buckley argue with someone is a surreal experience, easily preferable in contrast.