From a single data point? You don't.
You need to be able to gain the same information from other sources to corroborate it, and weighted based upon trust criteria. A known good trustworthy source in your web of trust outweighs neutral sources. A series of confirmations from other, disparate, seemingly-trustworthy sources that do not have a likely bias toward the information also count positively.
At the end of the day some part of it is subjective, yes, but you can gain confidence in the accuracy of a source with third-party corroboration.