Other examples of useless shit they done:
* giving Obama the peace price after he failed to shut down Guantanamo
* giving president of Colombia the peace price after he failed to make peace with FARC.
Other examples of useless shit they done:
* giving Obama the peace price after he failed to shut down Guantanamo
* giving president of Colombia the peace price after he failed to make peace with FARC.
This part is true, but that's because Nobel explicitly specified it this way. The peace prize is one of the original "real" ones. As opposed to the one for economics, which was made up later by others.
(And, well, that contributions to world peace are judged by "different rules and criteria" than physics... makes some sense.)
I think this difference in _who_ is doing the awarding and how they are related to the people receiving the awards is what dagw was trying to get at above. It's the difference between experts in a field selecting prizes for other members of their field and democratically-elected politicians playing political football with prizes in a field they themselves are totally not involved in and likely not much interested in to start with. :(
Chemistry, physics, physiology and medicine are sciences that have practitioners. Literature is an art that has practitioners. But peace is not a science nor an art. Nevertheless, Alfred Nobel saw fit to set up the peace prize. The rumor is that he did this because of hurt feelings after being accused of profiting from munitions manufacturing (he made his fortunes through inventions in explosives).
Of course there is a difference in who is doing the awarding. Nobel's decision to give the prize-awarding responsibility to Norwegian parliament might have had something to do with knowing peace activists at the time when Sweden and Norway were approaching the dissolution of their union, and there was fear of war.
I can't really point out any significantly better subject matter experts in working for peace than Norwegian Parliament.
In hindsight, it _may_ have been a good idea to have a process in place for handing off to a better-suited body at some point (e.g. past prize recipients, the UN). Hard to say, of course.
No, I trust the Norwegian parliament and its assigned panel a lot more. Nobel Peace Prize and its reputation is theirs. So far they've done a decent job, even if some of the appointments - like the premature selection of Obama - are disappointing.
I trust them more than the UN too, fwiw, but that's because it's a really low bar.
> Nobel Peace Prize and its reputation is theirs.
Yes, but they don't seem to care very much about its reputation.
> So far they've done a decent job
This opinion is not universally shared.
That is a weird way to put it, considering that nominations for the peace prize closed just 11 days after Obama took office, and the prize was awarded 9 months later.
It's more reasonable to say that prize was given to Obama based on his campaign promises, before he even had any actual chance to close Guantanamo. (Which he still hasn't done, because obviously it is much easier to talk about it in a campaign than to really create a sustainable policy for what to do with the detainees.)
The Obama thing I agree was rather ridiculous, as were various other Peace Prize awards.