It looks like it's going to be necessary to get serious about ingress filtering. See RFC 2827, which laid out the basics. Fortunately, there aren't that many ISPs left. If Comcast, AT&T, and Verizon got serious about ingress filtering, it would cut way down on the number of devices that could get through with a random IP source address. The ISPs are in a good position to tell their customers to unplug whatever is causing the trouble. (Assuming it's not the ISP's own router, which they should be able to fix remotely.)
At the big-pipe level, there should be sampling. 1 in 10000 packets has been suggested, which will reveal any massive attack without hurting privacy much. If a big pipe has an excessive fraction of attack packets, that indicates the sending end isn't doing proper ingress filtering. That's a matter to be dealt with between network operators, possibly with involvement from CERT and Homeland Security if necessary.
This problem is solveable, but it's going to take some ass-kicking. There are now enough big companies annoyed about this for that to happen.