It's kind of a radical new thing for humanity that we now have the means to provide lives, even meaningful ones, to people who prove themselves too dangerous to live in open society. We should at least give it a try.
It definitely isn't impossible to have that as the average standard.
The question you might be asking is why the "bleeding hearts" like me aren't. For me at least, that would be because I believe that culpability for actions is a continuum. Hell, I even think sentience is a continuum. At some point, criminal tendencies cross a blurry line from willful malfeasance into mental disability. Because I can't reliably determine this point and I don't trust those passing judgment not to let their prejudices and biases influence their thirst for vengeance, I prefer a system that uses extra caution.
We have the material resources to provide meaningful lives to these individuals for their entire natural lives. Not "5 star" accommodations mind you, but far from the hellish gulags we have now.
Lashing out in deadly anger feels awesome, I freely admit. But how many are on life sentences for no less?
I don't see it as 'vengeance' if they aren't pampered. There is a broad range between gulag and the Hilton.
That being said, those who in short-term should have some environment suited for rehabilitation, which probably includes learning that "wow jail sucks, i will remember that next time before I punch someone". Obviously they should be given the chance for education and employment, but the latest Playstation games might not be a necessity.
Like adopting a stray god and putting them on a leash is OK, but putting some bum on a leash is bad?
What kind of silly question is this? Not everything applies to humans and/or all species the same.
A lot of things apply to humans and not other species...