tl;dr: there's no evidence to suggest it is effective, and much evidence to the contrary.
tl;dr: there's no evidence to suggest it is effective, and much evidence to the contrary.
People care about saving people from being killed by the state, they care much, much less about them having their lives totally destroyed by it. The resources devoted to exonerating people facing the death penalty dwarf those spent on helping people sentenced to life, or some lesser sentence that still destroys your life, like a ten year prison sentence.
Yes, but the assumption is not mine. It is an axiom of our criminal legal-justice system, namely: punishment deters future crimes.
> My world-view is that the death penalty is a form of punishment for serious crime. It is not meant as a deterrent, not meant as some "lesson" for others. And I, personally, see no problem with it as a form of penalty to be payed by some. (I also reject Blackstone's formulation)
Punishment without social purpose is sadism.
I suspect I misunderstand your position. The answers to the following may help me understand.
If you are advocating for punishment without a useful social purpose (like deterring future crimes):
1. Why limit the death penalty to serious crimes? 2. Why punish at all, if it achieves nothing? 3. What do you think the death penalty should achieve?
It's just a thought exercise – no real need to reply.
> The vast majority of trials
You skirt the question. It said "those killed because trial went wrong and an innocent man was sentenced". So it asked exactly about those that you exclude.I don't. They are dead. They got unlucky. I reject the idea that we can't have capital punishment because sometimes the outcome of a trial is wrong. If you think this is a real problem then quantify it. Put down exactly what the percentage is (i.e. out of every X trials how many "go wrong" as you say). Then we can talk about a feasible upper bound. To say "If the percentage of people wrongly convicted is > 0% then we can never have a death penalty" is too idealistic. If it's 10% then it's obviously too high. Now we have a lower bound and an upper bound and can have a debate about what is an acceptable number of innocents dying. (again, 0 is infeasible).
> One person is one person too many!
This is the Blackstone principle. As I have said in the first post, I reject this. We both seem to disagree on a "first principle".
> Put down exactly what the percentage is.
That statement makes no sense at all! There have been proven cases (headlines about people freed from death row more than once in the last few years; and no, that's not a sign that "the system works", quite the opposite), so there is no question that they exist. Asking the obviously impossible and completely unconnected question "how many exactly" makes no sense, what would that achieve, even if it were possible?One person is one person too many!
I am all for weighing risk or cost vs. benefit, but what would be the benefit of killing people, apart from "revenge feeling"? Also paart from costs, because the death penalty AFAIK is very costly to the US taxpayer and I've read actually more expensive than life in prison.
So zero benefit against killing even one innocent person.
I'm not even someone who is dead set against killing.
So what is the purpose? "Punishment" seems an overtly emotional basis for such a stance, and "the dead got unlucky" seems rather callous. In my opinion, this is an awful lot of power that you are trusting to the state for weak reasons. Historically, the death penalty has been wielded by some people in power not just for crimes like murder, but also for more awful reasons like, say, people who had different opinions or were "other" ethnic groups etc. Were they unlucky too?
Even in America, where our criminal justice system for all its lumps and flaws is still better than many, we have probably killed a couple of innocent people (the Cameron Todd Willingham case being the strongest evidence of an innocent person being killed so far). We probably would have killed a lot more innocent people had our bar for actually performing the execution not been relatively high (149 exonerated from death row since 1973 according to this CBS News article in 2015 -- http://www.cbsnews.com/news/30-years-on-death-row-exoneratio...).
Is it? It is exactly the view I hold.
I propose that if you are willing to accept a higher rate, then on each conviction let us make it equally likely that the jury and prosecutor gets executed instead. 5% chance of killing an innocent? Only fair that the prosecutor and jury faces the same odds. Let's see how many are willing to take that risk if their own life is on the line.
1) That's how it is in many first-world countries, so it's obviously not too idealistic.
2) If you don't see the death penalty as a deterrent, what is that supposed pragmatic reason why it's needed (that makes absence of it idealistic)? That doesn't make sense.
The reason it is thrown up is because it does happen.
I presume there are also miscarriages of justice in the USA.
But, even if you don't agree, it's also in no way the cheapest or most effective way to handle this punishment. Google it. Here's one page for you: http://www.amnestyusa.org/our-work/issues/death-penalty/us-d...
That's what they say there. Doesn't mean that's what the society that sustains the laws believes...
For one, it gives people the message that murder, in some cases, is justified -- heck, even the state does it.
Second, after someone has done enough violent things to warrant capital punishment, every subsequent thing they do is free of any other punishment. Killed a cop during some robbery? Might as well try to shoot the whole lot down and escape, since I'm already certain to be put to death if caught.
Third, it also kills innocent people the same way actual murderers do. People that DNA or other evidence later exonerated.
The cold, calculating murderer that is happy to plan another murder is an extreme outlier.
As such capital punishment has exceedingly little effect on murder rates - most murderers don't believe they'll ever kill until they do, and are not in a state of mind to consider outcomes when they do. And once they have, the vast majority will never go on to kill again.
[1] EDIT: As in, extremely few will commit another murder.
And executing people who commit crimes for political or religious motives leads to notions of martyrdom and often encourages people of a like-mind to join their struggles.
Life imprisonment does much the same prevention job as the death penalty with much less baggage in terms of the ethics of killing people, or of the consequences of convicting innocent people, too.
Thousands of organs are transplanted every year.
The only way death penalty would make a dent would be to dramatically increase it.
But it wouldn't need to dramatically increase it to cause a massive percentage-wise increase in innocent people convicted.
Then what?
The reason there are so many on death row in the US today is that so many states have had issues with actually carrying out the executions - there are not 600 news capital convictions each year, so your supply would replenish at a much slower rate.
In other words unless you massively reduce the threshold at which you will convict, it will not provide much of a benefit. And given that we know that innocents get convicted, even a small reduction in the threshold will disproportionally increase the number of innocents convicted.
Want to solve the transplant issue? Instead of this, make people opt out istead of opt in to transplants.
And do you also propose that organ recipients be ranked according to how good they are as a person?
The thing is that many don't ever re-murder. With the proper systems in place, the majority of folks don't even wind up back in prison. IE, Norway's recidivism rate is around 20-25% :: The US hosts something like 52% at least with more than that being re-arrested for things.
Heck, the death penalty hasn't even been shown to prevent other folks from murdering folks. Neither have absurdly long prison sentences, including life in prison.