What were you researching/designing? The higher your clock speeds/bandwidth requirements are and the more complex your designs, the more locality matters. The last design I worked on, for example, was a 32x32 crosspoint switch with total bandwidth in the low hundreds of gigabits and we eventually had to tweak cell locations manually on the mask to get the design working to spec. In modern chip design, bandwidth on that scale is pretty common so i don't think we're talking about the extremes of hardware design.
>> I don't think this makes much sense unless you're presupposing a prescriptive physical layout. Sure, if you were to move a bunch of synthesized circuitry somewhere else and then try to reconnect it, it's not going to work. But that's not something you'd actually do in an abstract model.
Again, depends on a variety of factors. Some of the designs I've worked on have had internal clock signals that couldn't travel across a fraction of the chip before attenuating too much to switch a transistor. Sure a low speed design can be synthesized without caring about physical layout but once you're in the RF/high speed digital realm, the relative location of dependent high speed blocks matters much more and the HDL abstractions start to leak or breakdown entirely.