I beg to differ. They execute very well, but calling them that visionary is a little overboard.
I beg to differ. They execute very well, but calling them that visionary is a little overboard.
To him, the success iPhone achieved was unimaginable, and Steve Ballmer ain't no nobody in the industry. We can pretend that everybody else knew how and why the iPhone would become a staggering success, and only the very top guys in the industry were too blind to see it — but then we'd be lying to ourselves.
Nobody saw this coming. The concepts for what an "iPhone" would be, prior to Apple announcing it, were pathetic. Our collective imagination didn't go further than to imagine a regular phone with an Apple logo on it (or, how about a phone with an iPod click-wheel).
The iPad was largely being written off as a "big iPhone". The iPad is a "big iPhone" the way a swimming pool is a big bathtub — everything changes with scale. Played water sports in your bathtub lately?
Unimaginable — or lack of foresight due to insufficient imagination. That about sums it up.
After it came out, I doubt many people really thought it would fail. The potential was pretty obvious. Of course competitors will claim it's going to fail. What do you expect them to do? Encourage people to buy their competitions product?
The iPad. It is a big iPhone, with a few new interface elements. Yes, you can do more with it, but scaling up a bathtub hardly a stunning idea. Perhaps the first swimming pool was an engineering feat, but not a feat of imagination.
The same way a swimming pool is just a big bathtub, it makes all the difference in the world. You can't do the same things in a bathtub as you can in a swimming pool, or a lake, or an ocean. Scale changes everything.
They're not the first ones out with something new. Instead, they are consistently the first ones out with something that works really well across the entire User Experience. To do that, they have to make sure they wait until the technology can support the sort of UX they want to present.
It doesn't pay to just be visionary. Plenty of visionary people tried to build a flying machine before the Wright Brothers. In many cases, the technology they had access to just wasn't strong enough, light enough, or powerful enough.
e.g. the gym I go to has a new set of exercise machines that have iPod connections on them - I can plug in my iPod (which has a lot of ripped DVDs in it) and watch the movie through the large screen on top of the machine rather than using the tiny iPod screen.
The experience is just weird (and this may just mostly be because I'm used to the way iPods work so I have skewed expectations). The design is trying to be edgy but it just comes off as weird and awkwardly non-functional. The software just doesn't work as well. The store functionality isn't even close to iTunes.
I think Microsoft could top the iPod (and some things on the Zune are really cool UI-wise), but they've got a long way to go. They would basically need to take the shine they have on the device now and rethink the entire experience from a UX perspective to really get anywhere, though.