What I meant is that I find it unlikely that in such a group there would even be a strong moral reaction to any issue in the first place. I don't know about the extropian mailing list, but take LessWrong members, for instance. They are quite shameless about the topics they choose. And they're not much given to non-cognitive criticism either (e.g. calling someone an ass). So calling on "Crocker's rules" would be just redundant.
What is the point of ignoring something that doesn't happen?
Edit: On the other hand, it relies on the assumption that there's a trade-off between civility and informativeness which just might not be there.