If a car traveling 40 mph or faster hits a pedestrian or cyclist, the person hit will almost certainly die.
The two are really not comparable.
If we replaced all the drivers on the road with still-fallible but conscientious/polite human drivers who always followed traffic laws, always drove the speed limit, were effective at looking for and stopping for obstructions in the road (e.g. pedestrians crossing the street), followed at a safe distance, and adjusted their speed and following distance to match road conditions, the death rate from traffic collisions would drop dramatically.
If we replaced all the cyclists with perfect riders, the death rate from traffic collisions would change only marginally.