Comment by notoothpaste | Hacker News Reader

Comment by notoothpaste | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Thank you for your sincere and informed response.

I understand that EEs create countless prototypes over the course of the development of a product, and that development PCBs need not (especially for debugging purposes) bear any physical resemblance to the finished product.

What is impressive to me is that Toshiba could:

Redesign and test a PCB

Set up a manufacturing process for pick and place etc

Create an injection-molded case

Put it all together

Deliver all of this, on a whim, to a customer in the single digit quantities

And apparently do so to similar standards as their mass-produced machines

Did they just eat the cost of the most expensive PCB masks and injection molds, or is there something more interesting going on behind the scenes? That's what I want to know.

EDIT: I tripped the (whatever the fuck random sequence of characters you need to bypass the filters) filter and now I can't post any more for a few hours, otherwise I'd happily call all of you out as the ignorant yuppie douchebags you are... no, worse, the 19 year old CS majors pretending to be ignorant adult yuppie douchebags.

tl;dr I just wanted the chance to hear from experienced engineers. Please fuck off if you don't know what you're talking about, for the sake of anyone that wants to ask a remotely relevant question on this braindead hellhole.

You've commented uncivilly like this too many times; we have to ban this account. We're happy to unban accounts if you read the guidelines, email us at hn@ycombinator.com, and we believe you'll comment only civilly and substantively in the future.

You seem to want answers at a level that only the engineers at Fujitsu (not Toshiba, according to the OP) can provide. I can comment on some of the specific questions, but obviously I don't know what went on at Fujistsu.

1) The final development PCBs (the engineering validation articles) are actually identical to the production PCBs. Your final EV revision becomes revision 0 in production; only the manufacturing method changes. So the prototype floor definitely has the ability to make production-quality PCBs.

2) The design change may or may not be complicated. Adding a port typically refers to a port already supported by the chipset; so you add a ribbon connector for it and change the layout only.

3) You generally wouldn't have full pick-and-place automation for making prototypes. There are manual tools (sort of semi-automated) for making a few PCBs. A large company is making prototype PCBs all the time. They know how to do it, and they don't stop manufacturing for it.

4) For the case, the easiest would be to rework an existing case (add a slot). Creating custom injection molds is kind of a big deal. Then again, if Fujitsu does that in house, maybe not that big. Don't know.

5) The expense would not involve a cash outlay, but it would definitely involve diverting engineering, manufacturing and sales resources to even communicate and deliver this whole thing, let alone make it. The engineers may have been pulled off something, or may have been waiting for work; business hasn't been that great for most manufacturers, if you haven't noticed. No, I don't know how Fujitsu accounts for this or why they made the decision to go ahead. I am not a manager at Fujitsu. I can tell you that most companies are very loathe to let prototypes and one-offs to leave their hands at all. So it's definitely impressive on Fujitsu's part that they would go to that length.

> I'd happily call all of you out as the ignorant yuppie douchebags you are... no, worse, the 19 year old CS majors pretending to be ignorant adult yuppie douchebags.

> Please fuck off if you don't know what you're talking about, for the sake of anyone that wants to ask a remotely relevant question on this braindead hellhole.

Uh, what? did I miss something?

You missed a meltdown, I guess.

Degrees are expensive, and if you don't get to bludgeon people with them, what's the point?

This is the bad place to try to bludgeon people with your degrees. It kind of reminds me of two funny moments:

1. A group of British construction workers in a Discovery Channel documentary loved to start fights in random bars until one day they accidentally started a fight in a bar frequented by members of a local boxing club.

2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35079

Some of the external ports in my lifebook are simply mounted on the housing and connected to the boards by cable assemblies, so:

They may have stuck the needed connector on a wire and used an NC mill to make an appropriate cutout from an existing housing part.

It is literally less than 1 hour to design and tape-out a inch-square pc board to accomodate a connector and cable termination. I am a little guy and have to wait a week and pay five bucks to have this manufactured. Fujitsu probably had this done the morning after a solution to the request was devised and approved.

I think you are right, but the idea that they were willing and able to actually execute was incredible to me. Alot of competence and strong relationships were in place in the sales and manufacturing organization for that to happen.

As a customer, I think we bought ~1,000 units in the end. I've rarely seen that type of capability in my career, and it's too bad that the realities of the market have likely nixed it.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com