Hmmm.....
The thing is, until you actually manage money you can't really tell if you have alpha or if you are one of the million monkeys typing out a novel on a typewriter.
Are there people who aren't currently at funds who could be awesome quants?
Absolutely. Just working on the markets as a full time job is a large part of succeeding.
Can some of these strategies that quantopian users are coming up whit make money? Of course, alpha is everywhere.
The biggest hurdle is again taking the theory and putting it into practice. And then redoing it year over year. I mean making money from 2008 until now isn't really proof of much as the market has been up and to the right almost the entire time.I don't want to sound really dismissive, but until a quantopian fund successfully manages say 200 million with returns of S&P + 5% over a period of say 5 years its probably best to cool the hype:)
And I say this as someone who is a big fan of what they are doing. It's just in finance you see alot of hype and you learn very quickly, that the scoreboard is everything, nothing cuts through bullshit faster than actual returns data net of fees.
I've written alot about quantopian and them turning themselves into a fund of sorts if anyone is interested.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12335272#12336086