The tracking number showed the item delivered to the person, signed for with an known employee's name. I submitted this, as well as a picture of the item in the guy's shop. I still lost the chargeback. Got my revenge in the end though...see below.
A tip for anyone that's has a particular chargeback where they know they were screwed. If the issuing bank has any presence in your state...sue the cardholder's bank (or perhaps Visa/MC/AMEX) in small claims. In my case, Chase settled for the amount I sued for, which I made sure was on the high side. They don't like to spend money on corporate lawyers going to small claims.