A business operates on trust, this breaks that trust.
It's not just PR, it's a fundamental breach of the silent agreement between users and a service.
What your terms and conditions write in legalese and what you intend to do in plain English can be two different things but that isn't a long term strategy.
Nobody is going to sue posterous over this, mostly because there isn't any real damage to the end users, and yet they should have known much better than to even try and get away with this.